Vision Rally Tonight! (Oct. 5, 2011)
WHO – Organizers
The four independent, non-partisan people who organized the event are Kim Smythe, Andrea Rosato-Taylor, Donna Hais, Angie Barnard. To keep ticket prices to a minimum for the general public, we got sponsorship from businesses & organizations who we know personally & could mobilize finances quickly, and that supported our mandate for the rally.
WHO – Keynote speakers: Ken Melamed and Mike Harcourt
Learn how Whistler, BC took a hard look at their future after the Olympics and decided – between businesses, city hall and the community at large – what they would become ‘after’ being acclaimed as one of the top luxury ski resorts in North America. Mayor Ken Melamed shares how they plan to achieve sustainability and how they developed the “Whistler 2020 Vision” and a program called ‘iShift’. What role did each partner play, who were the real leaders in the process, who will carry that torch?
Then, hear one of the world’s foremost experts speak on the success and sustainability of cities in today’s world. Learn how community service and vision come together to build the communities of tomorrow. Find out how leadership, direction, and vision give a community greater strength. Spend some quality time with our keynote speaker for the evening: MIKE HARCOURT.
Former Premier of BC from 1991-96, twice Mayor of Vancouver, and multi-term City Councillor, Mr. Harcourt is an icon of community service and leadership. Since stepping away from politics in the mid-90’s, he has been appointed by the Prime Minister to the National Round Table on the Environment and Economy, where he chaired the Urban Sustainability Program. He was appointed a BC Treaty Commissioner and was Chair of the Prime Minister’s Advisory Committee for Cities and Communities. He co-chaired the UN Habitat World Forum in Vancouver in 2006. He is Chair of the UBC’s Regional Sustainability Council, and author of “A Measure of Defiance”, co-author of “Plan B: One Man’s Journey from Tragedy to Triumph” and co-author of “City Making in Paradise”.
WHAT – Public Rally
The general public of Nanaimo is invited to a ‘COMMUNITY VISION RALLY’. The two keynote speakers above admirably meet our objective to inspire Leadership, Community Service, and Change through their experience, speaking skills, and role modeling. We hope to attract a large audience of citizens interested in the future of their community. We hope to draw leaders from that audience of inspire those with thoughts of leadership that this is the time for them to step forward and share that ‘Network’ moment.
WHEN / WHERE / HOW
Wednesday 05 October 2011
Vancouver Island Conference Centre, 101 Gordon Street
6pm Doors Open (estimated 9pm finish)
Tickets $12.50 (tickets can be purchased at the door)
WHY – The motivation behind the Rally
The four of us came together because we were tired of having conversations at home complaining about a) the lack of a ‘can-do’ culture, and b) lack of sufficient private or public sector leaders who openly & progressively have the skills & vision to steer our community.
We took it upon ourselves and have working behind the scenes for months to develop strategies for a succession plan for ‘qualified leaders’, and to engage the support of individuals that have the capacity and ability to shape our future. The four of us do not necessarily support the same municipal candidates, but we individually and collectively support the same underlying principles of leadership (refer ‘Successful Cities’ criteria below).
One of our strategies we have brought to fruition is the ‘Community Vision Rally’. The mantra for the Rally is “Lead. Run. Vote.” Everyone in attendance at the rally should be committed to one – if not more than one of these, desired actions NOW in the lead up to the next election. We need CHANGE to redirect our collective energy towards a new, more positive, and productive future. We need fresh ideas, a disconnection from the status quo and ‘the way its always been done’, and a hunger to ‘reboot’ Nanaimo. We need inspired LEADERSHIP who want to open an entirely new book on the way business is conducted between city hall and its potential partners in economic development – those who understand and are committed to community consultation and support participatory government.
Most of all, we need large numbers of people who (and we know they exist) who will take this as their ‘Network’ moment.We also understand that the Community Vision Rally may be just the beginning depending on the community support demonstrated at the Rally. We suspect that new initiatives & projects will surface as a direct result of the Community Vision Rally, and we will be evaluating possible next steps after the event on Wednesday 05 October.
WHY – 10 Essential Elements to Nanaimo being a Successful City
- A Business Friendly Culture (Entrepreneurial Governance) If a city is to compete effectively it must seek to create a business-friendly environment. Unless it can generate large scale employment then it will not create the wealth that must underpin every aspect of its life and culture. This is no longer simply a matter of light regulation and low taxes, important as these are, but success also requires the fostering of a culture of research, innovation and education. Entrepreneurial governance demands strong civic leaders with a vision of where they want to take their city and an economic strategy that embraces partnership with local businesses.
- Quality of Life: Successful cities are places where people want to live. These communities are experiencing population growth at or “reasonably” above the national average. In a globalizing world, the creative people that cities need have many choices. The evidence is that they are attracted to cities which offer not just financial rewards but the quality of life to which they aspire. Cities are especially successful if they are able to attract more young, well-educated individuals than they lose – experiencing “brain gain” (as opposed to a “brain drain”). This will create a skilled workforce and foster a culture of innovation, research and development AND pride of place.
- Culture of Collaboration: Successful communities are able to create and sustain an atmosphere of “civic collaboration” that balances the ability to “get things done” with today’s public desire for openness and inclusiveness. We expect our civic leaders to move the community forward, but we also want to have a say in the process. Collaboration and partnerships are the vehicles of community-based innovation and local governments have a lead role in organizing and convening the processes.
- Sustainability: The most successful cities will be those that combine efforts to take a long-term view in formulating plans and policies, and work to make them relevant to their own particular situations. For economic development to be successful, it needs to be sustainable. Careful consideration should be given to balancing economic, social and environmental objectives to achieve improved quality of life and sustainable growth. Sustainable communities are able to attract people because they create a positive image of a place to live and conduct business and it is important for local governments to recognize this connection and, where possible, incorporate sustainability into their economic development approach
- Culture of Innovation: The introduction of new techniques and processes is the key to creating the knowledge-based industries that generate high standards of living. Over the last 30 years, a large part of the growth in output in developed countries has resulted from innovation. Innovation depends on a strong research and innovation base and the creation of networks, involving both the public and private sectors, for generating and sharing knowledge. Successful cities have leadership that accepts reality of this “New Economy” and understands that it is changing everything for cities across the globe. (The “New Economy” refers to the transition from an industrial/manufacturing-based economy to knowledge/human-capital-based economy).
- Connectivity: Good communications both to the outside world and within the city are crucial. Without a good airport and, where appropriate, ports and international rail links, no city can make the leap to world league status. Similarly, good internal communications, underpinned by adequately funded public transport provide the essential infrastructure for the movement of people, goods and services.
- Diversity: Successful cities appreciate that economic, cultural and social diversity make for a vibrant city. A diverse economy is better equipped to weather economic cycles. Cities that embrace diversity in all its forms including cultural and ethnic diversity are better equipped to generate the creativity that cities need, making themselves attractive to the skilled migrants that have been so integral to the economic success of cities around the world.
- Distinctiveness: Successful cities are those that have a particular identity that helps them attract businesses, skilled workers, visitors and students. Often this may involve strengths in the creative and cultural sectors, which can in turn impact on economic success. A vital part of this distinctiveness is “Pride of Place”.
- Physical Renewal: The physical regeneration of cities – the renewal of its buildings and infrastructure-is almost invariably a key part of any successful urban strategy. In many cases the renewal of a key area of the city acts as a focus for national and international attention as well as generating civic pride and the ‘buzz’ that the city is on the move. But physical regeneration only works if it is combined with social regeneration – the creation of real communities with the services including health and education needed to support them.
- Transportation: Successful city’s underpinning is public transportation, whether bus, commuter train, light rail or streetcar. Public transit provides citizens with transportation choices. And, there has never been a better time for cities to build, improve or expand those systems.
Our city is a mosaic of people from many walks of life. Here is a take from a person who lives at the poverty level.
Transportation-More than six thousand people live far below the the accepted standards for sustenance in our city. Transportation for many of them is a non issue, as they cannot even afford busfare. Getting to and from job interviews is a matter of which ones they can walk to. The bus connections are not optimized for a person to get to and from work, at the northend or the southend. If a person has to work late at a Macdonalds, or a seven eleven, or even some bars, they have no way to get home at night.
Physical renewal-Do we mean more of new office buildings for city staff, more brand new infrastructure like the VICC, cruise ship terminal and a new train station without a running train? The attitude of the last number of years has been ‘if we build it they will come” Our city core has many condos that are not even close to full. We are building shelters and new low barrier places that cost a fortune,while many servicable buildings are empty. I read in the papers that downtown is revitalized. I live downtown and I have lived here for 27 years. I see empty office buildings. I see new businesses every year that are going under or relocatiing. I see a public square that is empty 90% of the time. No water fountain in the square, no comfortable places to sit and gossip, or people watch.Cafes downtown geared for tourists or people who have money. How about places to eat or have a coffee that the less fortunate could afford to go to? I am talking here about ordinary folks who cannot afford $12.00 for lunch!
No street vendors selling hot chestnuts, Dim Sum or ethnic foods. How about affordable places for everyone to shop in all areas of the city? Ever notice that the cheapest places to shop are not in areas that can be accessed by those who have the most need for cheaper items? All areas of the city must be included in order for the whole city to have civic pride and a buzz. Like many seasonal places, downtown Nanaimo seems to want to cater to a certain group of customers. If a base of Nanaimo people were to be able to afford to shop downtown there might be less expensive stuff sold but at least volume of sales would be generated. If the only time downtown is busy is when a cruise ship comes in ,we are in serious trouble.
Distintiveness-Nanaimo is supposed to be a gathering place. The indigenous people, the coal mining history, the logging history, the wonderful Chinese contribution to our city are not on display. Instead we feature arts and culture that is gentrified, a scrap iron sculpture at Diana Krall plaza, piano keys made of brick that are fading fast. Bricks and cement are an integral part of our downtown , the waterfront walkway and Swy-a-lana. Music only rings through our streets when it is “sponsored” . We dont want spontanious “happenings” like one sees in Vancouver. Events and festivals must fit a certain criteria in order to happen. God forbid we should be allowed to have acrobats, circus performers or jam sessions in the streets. You cant even sing in a public place without a Bylaw Officer giving you a ticket! Our Canada Day celebrations are a joke! Everyone is crammed into Swy-a-lana like sardines, and there is no parking to be had for the number of people who attend. No fireworks on the most important day of our country, and everything shuts down early. Our distinctness lies in the number of bars we have and the number of malls in the northend.
Diversity-Our city is made up of people from everywhere in the world. We have students from around the globe. Are we creative in the manner that we welcome these students? Who greets them when they arrive? Where do they gather? I stay in hostels in Vncouver when I go there to play music. I talk to people from all over the world. There are many cultural centres in Vancouver where students can gather to have coffee , or a drink, listen to world music and dance. Why dont we have a welcoming place for our visitors.,one that is not just there to sell them something?
Connectivity-No bus service to the airport $40.00, no bus service to Duke Point $40.00, if you catch the late ferry home to Nanaimo you are likely to miss the last city bus to get you to whereever you live in Nanaimo $20.00 minimum. Where do people without a computer or a car have to go to get to Shaw cable? Can you pay your hydro, telus, or fortis bill in an area where you live? Until recently most of our banks were gone from downtown. Where is our Post Office. Ever try to get there on foot? i love to go to a bank or a store that the empoyees know my name. I want to be able to walk to amenities.
Culture of innovation-knowledge based industries are indeed the key to revitalizing our city. Knowledge in the new world era means that the powers that be such as the City Council, Chamber of Commerce recognize that old ways must change. The web connects us to everyplace on the globe. We are part of a global economy, jobs that are shipped out to other countries can happen here. We still have relatively cheap power to fuel technological engines. My son’s business has almost 40 employees , young people, many of whom were raised and educated in this city. He had to buy and renovate a building in order to expand his growing business. If those in charge of The VICC had had enough sense to lower their price per square foot, there might have been an extremely viable and long term tenant there!
The most important component of all is vision. What do we want to see for our citizens first? A community that takes care of its own business first, is one that will be reflected in the eyes of visitors. Part of that vision is preserving the old , reusing buildings that we can, maintaining our streets , our hospitals, our schools and our parks. We need to work with what we have, and make a foundation before we spend millons of dollars to remake what is already a beautiful city. Dont fix what isnt broke. Look after our seniors, our kids and our families. Do a core review at City Hall and find the waste if there is any. Budget for what the taxpayers can afford. no pipe dreams or pie in the sky. Consult the taxpayers of this city and be transparent in all governance.
I forgot to mention that I cannot afford to go to this “Vision rally’ and neither can many of the residents who live here.Many seniors, and others have no mode of transportation to get to this rally.A pretty sad state of affairs when only the elite can participate in a “vision rally’.
A list of plans and visions for Nanaimo . . .
The Deverell plan 1891:
http://www.viu.ca/history/nanaimo/map.htm
The Deverell plan was so imminently creative and lasting because it addressed, quite unconsciously, the constraints of topography and economics of its time.
Spaxman plan 1993:
Click to access PEDSC041206A.pdf
City of Nanaimo annual report 2004:
Click to access 2004AnnualMunicipalReport.pdf
Check out “our Values” page 14 and don’t be cynical.
Plan Nanaimo 1998:
No record exists on line. A very intelligent approach describing development as a series of villages that counteract the uncontrolled, environmentally and economically unsustainable, speculator driven sprawl that defines Nanaimo today.
FPN plan for Nanaimo 2004:
No record exists on-line. A downtown alternative to VICC. Councilor Krall described it as an inappropriate 19th century English mining town.
Kemble Plan for Nanaimo 2002-6:
http://www.theyorkshirelad.ca/2renewnan/front.html
OCP Nanaimo 2008
Click to access OfficialCommunityPlan2008.pdf
D’Ambrosio plan for Nanaimo 2008
Click to access 0617_NDG.pdf
With the exception of the Deverell plan all ignored.
And so, this evening, we have the choice of two conflicting meetings to discuss a new vision for Nanaimo. The “visioning” process flies in the face of historic and cultural influences that have described human settlements for thousands of years . . .
http://members.shaw.ca/urbanismo/city/city.html
. . . don’t expect this evening to be any different.
Good luck! QED
Roger: While FPN may no longer be playing on the nets I-way’, there is a relict piece of its work left in the form of a book: Nanaimo between Past and Future: Critical Perspectives on Growth, Planning and the New Nanaimo Centre. It is available at our Public Library and there may even be a few copies for sale still floating around.
My only response to this is why does it take people outside of City Hall to figure out there must be a vision? What are we paying our City Manager and those around him for if they can not come up with a plan for Nanaimo? I don’t get it. They seem to be able to fit in all the new bylaws, against having a Core Review of the city done. Wrote some major words there on that one. What are they afraid of? I can only guess.
The most important component to a properly functioning democracy has long since withdrawn from the process. Part of the reason is stated in Lynn’s comment:
“What are we paying City Managers for”………..
We show up to vote (only 30%) every three years and leave 9 people to it thinking we have done our duty.
Lynn…… WE are the problem.
@ Jim . . . WE are the problem. Unfortunately how true!
We can all thank the folks who pulled the Rally together, wish them good luck, pledge our participation in the next step, and hope against hope for some hope in a stale and stalemated situation. Change in our public attitudes -and particularly those of our elected representatives- is sorely needed.
Key to a successful and sustainable City is inclusiveness form the highest paid to the lowest, including the disenfranchised.
Gord:
Can you define inclusiveness??? Also a ‘sustainable’ city? Also disenfranchised??